Zainab’s First Debate

A story about reasoning, respect and learning from losing.

Zainab joined the debating team because she was sure she could win. She had opinions on everything, and she loved to argue with her brother at dinner. “How hard can it be?” she thought. Her coach, Ms Ferris, smiled and said, “Let us see.”

Her first debate was against a rival school. The topic was, “That homework should be banned.” Zainab was on the affirmative side. She had written a speech full of passion, telling the judges that homework was a waste of time and that everyone hated it. She delivered it with fire.

The opposition speaker stood up calmly. She quoted three studies, and used a clear structure. She answered every point Zainab had made. She spoke slowly, and made eye contact with the judges. When she sat down, Zainab’s heart sank. She knew they had lost.

The judges agreed. “Zainab, you spoke with great energy,” said one. “But your argument lacked evidence, and you did not respond to the other side.” Zainab’s cheeks burned. In the car park, she kicked a tyre. “I hate losing,” she muttered.

Ms Ferris gave her a long, kind look. “A debate is not about shouting louder,” she said. “It is about understanding the other side as well as your own.” She gave Zainab a notebook. “Next time, try this. Write down the strongest argument against your position.”

Zainab was surprised. It seemed strange to argue against herself. But she tried it. For the next topic, she wrote the opposing view in full. She found that some of its points were good. It made her think harder about her own position.

At the next debate, she spoke more calmly. She used three examples, and she replied directly to what the other team said. When the opposition made a good point, she said, “That is a fair point, but here is why I still disagree.” The judges nodded.

This time, she won. Her teammates cheered. But what pleased her most was how she felt. She had changed her mind about one small thing during preparation, and it had not felt like losing. It had felt like learning.

After the debate, a boy from the opposing team came over and shook her hand. “That was a great argument,” he said. “Thanks.” Zainab grinned. “You too,” she said. She was beginning to love debating for more than the winning.

Print a homework planner →