The Photograph That Was Not Perfect

A story about authenticity, self-image and being comfortable with yourself.

Hallie loved photography. She had a good phone camera and an eye for light. She posted her pictures online, and she spent hours editing each one. She smoothed her skin, brightened her smile, and made the colours pop. When she was done, they looked like magazine pages.

But something felt wrong. She noticed that she hardly recognised herself in the pictures. The girl in the photos had flawless skin and perfect teeth, and she did not look like Hallie at all. When she looked in the mirror, she felt a pang of disappointment.

One Saturday, she went to a lake with her friends Jess and Omar. They swam and laughed and ate sandwiches on the grass. Omar took a photo of Hallie mid-laugh, with her hair wild and her eyes squeezed shut. She had a smudge of sunscreen on her cheek.

“Delete that,” she said at once. “I look terrible.” Omar shook his head. “Are you joking? That is the best photo of the day,” he said. “You look happy.” He turned the phone round. Hallie looked. She did look happy, genuinely, with her whole face.

That night, she looked at the photo again. The smudge of sunscreen was silly, and her hair was a mess. But there was a warmth to it that none of her edited photos had. She thought about the hours she spent smoothing out every bump.

On a whim, she posted the photo without any edits. She added a short caption. “Me, on a good day.” Then she put her phone down and went to make dinner. When she came back an hour later, her screen was full of notifications.

Friends had written comments. “This is gorgeous!” “So real.” “I love your laugh.” A girl she barely knew wrote, “Thank you for posting this. I never see photos that look like real people.” Hallie felt a warm lump in her throat.

She realised that people had never wanted a perfect Hallie. They wanted the real one. From then on, she limited her editing to simple adjustments, like light and colour. She stopped changing her face. She felt calmer, and her photos got better.

A few months later, she held an exhibition at school called “Unfiltered.” It had portraits of her friends, all natural, with their freckles and crooked smiles. A teacher said, “These are the most honest images I have ever seen.” Hallie beamed.

Print dot grid paper for sketching →